The Comfortable Illusion of Green Growth

and the Story We Need Instead

2025-11-05

Michiel Knoppert

There is a comforting idea circulating in politics, journalism and industry today: that we can keep economic growth going while reducing environmental harm. Through cleaner technology, smarter design and better policy, we could maintain our comfort, convenience and prosperity — without destroying the planet that sustains us. The central fear many people have — does climate action mean giving up the good life? — would vanish. We could simply innovate our way to a greener version of life as we know it.

It is an appealing story. We all want a hopeful future that doesn’t require sacrifice or discomfort. But the risk of a comforting story is that it can lull us into complacency. And when we look closely, the Green Growth narrative begins to crack.

Because if economic growth truly leads to mental space, social stability and ecological care, why are those qualities declining fastest in the wealthiest societies on Earth?

Above a certain level of material comfort, wellbeing does not increase. Stress, loneliness, burnout and lifestyle-related disease become defining features of affluent life. The things that truly allow humans to thrive — time, connection, meaning, purpose — are squeezed rather than expanded by endless increases in choice and convenience. Material wealth is not the same as real wellbeing, and more of it often undermines our psychological and social foundations instead of strengthening them.

Green Growth assumes that sustainability naturally follows prosperity. But the environmental gains in rich countries are largely achieved by exporting pollution and extraction to poorer regions. Our statistics look clean only because the damage takes place out of sight, in the places that make our goods, mine our metals and process our waste. The living world, however, does not recognize these bookkeeping tricks. Biodiversity continues to collapse. Forests and coral reefs disappear. Entire ecosystems approach irreversible tipping points. We are not cleaning up — we are outsourcing harm.

Meanwhile, the promise of technology itself contains a trap. When efficiency improves, total consumption tends to rise rather than fall. Cheaper and cleaner flights encourage more flying. Smarter devices lead to more devices. Faster logistics increase global throughput. Even renewable energy requires unprecedented volumes of metals and minerals. As long as expansion remains the goal, efficiency becomes fuel for growth, not a brake on impact. A green global machine is still a machine that devours the world.

There is also a deeper form of risk — a cultural and existential one. The Green Growth story defines the “good life” as uninterrupted consumption, just made more efficient and less guilty. We remain spectators rather than participants in our own world: dependent on complex systems we neither understand nor control. We continue outsourcing our food, our tools, our care, our skills, our safety — almost every aspect of living. Progress becomes measured only in what we can purchase, never in what we can create together.

If this is hope, it is a thin and fragile one.

There is, fortunately, another hopeful story. It begins from a simple observation: once our basic material needs are met, the sources of true richness lie elsewhere. They are found in meaningful relationships, in having agency over our own lives, in creativity and craft, in physical and mental health, in belonging to places, and in a sense of partnership with the living world. These forms of welfare do not require endless resource extraction. They grow through connection rather than consumption. And they flourish not by escaping our interdependence with land and community, but by renewing it.

A person who knows the seasons because their food depends on them — even a little — experiences the world differently from someone whose nourishment arrives in anonymous packages. A neighborhood where people share tools and skills becomes a network of mutual support, not just a set of adjacent living units. A child who climbs trees, digs in dirt and roams the local park grows up not only healthier, but more rooted in life. These are not luxuries. They are the foundations of a resilient and caring society.

The story we need is not about decoupling humans from nature so growth can continue without guilt. It is about re-connection — with sources of sustenance, with the places we inhabit, and with one another. It is about recovering skills and capacities that industrial convenience has allowed to atrophy. It is about recognizing that wellbeing is not delivered to us by distant systems, but cultivated where we stand.

Green Growth offers reassurance: you can keep living as you do.
Reconnection offers something far better: a chance to rediscover what life is for.

The question is not whether we can save our wellbeing while preserving the growth model. The question is whether we can finally acknowledge that real progress means growing beyond it — as humans and as communities.

Sources
A curated selection of research underpinning this article:
Decoupling, growth, and environmental impact
Jason Hickel (2020) – EKC critique: https://www.jasonhickel.org/blog/2020/10/9/response-to-mcafee
Environmental Kuznets Curve review (2015): https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282598056_The_Environmental_Kuznets_Curve
IPBES Global Assessment Report (2019): https://files.ipbes.net/ipbes-web-prod-public-files/webform/impact_tracking_database/46408/2019%20IPBES%20Biodiversity%20and%20Ecosystem%20Services%20report%20Final.pdf
IEA Critical Minerals Outlook (2024): https://www.iea.org/reports/global-critical-minerals-outlook-2024
CBS (2025) — Critical Raw Materials: https://www.cbs.nl/en-gb/longread/rapportages/2025/dutch-dependency-on-critical-raw-materials
Global Carbon Project (2024): https://globalcarbonproject.org/fossil-fuel-co2-emissions-increase-again-in-2024/
Lange et al. (2021) — Rebound effects: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S221462962100075X
Wellbeing vs. material wealth
LSE (2025) — Easterlin Paradox Revisited: https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/inequalities/2025/06/25/the-easterlin-paradox-revisited
OECD (2024) — Loneliness & Social Connections: https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/social-connections-and-loneliness-in-oecd-countries_6df2d6a0-en.html
WHO (2023) — Loneliness Public Health Threat: https://www.who.int/news/item/15-11-2023-who-launches-commission-to-reignite-connections
Holt-Lunstad et al. (2010): https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.1000316
Putnam (2000) – Bowling Alone: https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Bowling-Alone/Robert-D-Putnam/9780743203043
Connection to nature, place & community
Macro-level Nature Connectedness study (2025): https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s13280-025-02275-w
Biophilia Hypothesis (1993)
Last Child in the Woods (2005)
Kuo (2015) — Nature & Human Health: https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.01093/full
Blue Zones (2016–2023): https://www.bluezones.com
Pinkster (2021) — Neighborhood belonging: https://journalofurbanism.com
Illich (1971–1981) — conviviality theories

Let's get Uncivilized!

We’re just getting started, and we’re looking for the right allies to shape this journey. If you’re a business at the edge of transformation, wondering how to grow without giving up what made your work meaningful—let’s talk. If you’re curious to test the Uncivilize framework in practice, we want to learn with you.

This is an open invitation to anyone ready to explore what comes after business-as-usual.

Let's get Uncivilized!

We’re just getting started, and we’re looking for the right allies to shape this journey. If you’re a business at the edge of transformation, wondering how to grow without giving up what made your work meaningful—let’s talk. If you’re curious to test the Uncivilize framework in practice, we want to learn with you.

This is an open invitation to anyone ready to explore what comes after business-as-usual.